Home / Fence Guides

Fence Guide · 4 min read

Pine vs. Cedar Fence: Which Lasts Longer in Texas?

Pressure-treated pine saves a few dollars a foot. Cedar stays straighter and holds off rot on its own. Here's how the two compare around Magnolia and Pinehurst.

By the 76 Fence of Magnolia team · Updated

Most of the wood fences we build around Magnolia, Pinehurst, and Montgomery are either cedar or pressure-treated pine, and the cedar vs. pine fence question comes up on almost every estimate. Both make a good privacy fence. They just wear differently in our heat and humidity, and the cheaper board up front isn't always the cheaper fence ten years later.

Here's how the two compare on the things that decide it for most owners: price, rot and bugs, how the boards hold their shape, upkeep, and lifespan.

Cedar vs. pine fence cost

Pine is the budget end of wood fencing. Using the ballpark ranges in our pricing guide, pressure-treated pine runs about $25–$35 per installed foot and cedar about $30–$47. Height, gates, tear-out of an old fence, and board-on-board versus side-by-side all move the final number.

On a typical backyard, that gap is real but not huge. On a long run across an acreage tract, a few dollars a foot adds up fast, which is one reason pine shows up more often on big lots outside town.

Rot, termites, and the ground line

The two woods protect themselves in different ways. Pine resists rot because it's pressure-treated with a preservative. Cedar's resistance is natural, from oils in the heartwood. That natural protection is strongest in the darker heartwood and weaker in the pale sapwood, so board quality matters.

The weak spot on either fence is the first few inches above the soil. Sandy topsoil here drains fast, but the clay layer underneath can hold water, so the base of a fence can stay damp for days after a heavy rain. Pine needles banked against the bottom rail make it worse. That's why every wood fence we build gets a rot board, and why plenty of cedar fences go up on treated pine or galvanized steel posts. Treated lumber is labeled for above-ground or ground-contact use, and posts need the ground-contact kind.

Cedar also holds off termites better than untreated wood. Neither species makes a fence termite-proof, so keep soil and mulch off the boards either way.

Warping, twisting, and looks

This is where cedar earns most of its price. Pine tends to twist, cup, and check more as it dries out through a Texas summer, and treated pine often arrives wet from the treating process, so it shrinks once it's up. Expect some gaps between pine pickets after the first hot stretch. Cedar is lighter, more stable, and stays flatter.

On looks, cedar has the warm, reddish tone most people picture, and it weathers to a soft silver if you leave it alone. Pine starts out pale or slightly green and looks more utilitarian bare, but it takes stain well, so a stained pine fence can look very close to cedar from the street.

Staining and upkeep

Both woods want the same care here. Plan on cleaning and a fresh coat of penetrating stain roughly every 2 to 4 years, sooner on runs that take full south or west sun. The difference is timing on a new fence. Cedar can usually be stained within the first few months. Wet treated pine needs to dry out first or the stain won't soak in, so ask your installer when the boards are ready. Our staining and power washing crew handles both.

Lifespan around Magnolia

Pressure-treated pineCedar
Installed cost per footAbout $25–$35About $30–$47
Rot resistanceFrom chemical treatmentNatural, best in heartwood
Shape in summer heatMore twisting, cupping, gapsStays flatter and straighter
First stain on a new fenceAfter the boards dry outUsually within a few months
Typical life hereAbout 10 to 15 yearsAbout 15 to 20 years, stained on schedule

Those lifespans assume the posts were set right. In the loose sand that covers most lots around Magnolia and Pinehurst, a shallow post leans long before the boards wear out, whatever wood is on it. We set every wood fence post at least 24 inches deep in 80 pounds of concrete, deeper and wider in loose sand or wet ground, and more at gates and corners. More on that in our guide to fence posts in Montgomery County soil.

Which one we'd pick

  • Choose pine for long runs on acreage, rental properties, a fence you plan to stain anyway, or a firm budget where every foot counts.
  • Choose cedar for the backyard you look at every day, a neighborhood with a cedar spec, or if you want straighter boards and fewer gaps over time.
  • Mix them when it makes sense: treated pine or steel posts with cedar pickets, or cedar near the house and pine along the back property line.

If you're weighing the two, we're happy to price both side by side on the same written estimate. Call or text (281) 292-1897, or set up a free estimate and we'll walk the line with you.

Quick answers

Can I mix cedar pickets with pressure-treated pine posts?

Yes, and it’s a common build. Treated pine is the stronger, cheaper choice for the posts that sit in the ground, and cedar pickets give you the look and the straighter boards on the face. Galvanized steel posts behind cedar are another option if you want posts that won’t rot or feed termites.

Will my HOA care whether the fence is cedar or pine?

Some do. Many deed-restricted neighborhoods around Magnolia write cedar into their fence spec, and others only regulate height, style, and stain color. Check your guidelines before you buy lumber; our HOA fencing page covers the approval side.

Do you replace just the pickets on an old pine fence?

If the posts and rails are still solid, we can re-picket a section in cedar or pine. If the posts are rotted at grade or leaning, new boards on a failing frame won’t last, and we’ll tell you that up front.

Keep reading

Page

Wood & Cedar Fencing in Magnolia, TX

Read more →
FAQ

How long does a fence last around Magnolia?

Rough lifespan ranges by material, where fences wear out first on local lots, and what you can do to push the replacement date further out.

Read more →
Fence Guide

Composite vs. Wood Fence: Which Makes Sense for Your Property?

Composite costs at least twice as much to install as cedar. Here's what that money buys, and the lots where wood is still the better call.

Read more →

Ready for a free estimate?

Call or text us, or book a time for us to walk your property and give you a written quote.